Case Studies: Nippur, Egypt, and Iran
The Penn Museum became the first U.S. museum to excavate in the Middle East when it led an expedition to Nippur (in modern-day Iraq) in 1889. At the time, Nippur was governed by the Ottoman Empire, which was becoming increasingly reluctant to give up its objects. However, after diplomatic negotiations, Ottoman authorities granted the Penn Museum a permit to excavate. The Penn Museum agreed to engage in partage (a French word meaning sharing) that is, in a system of dividing discovered artifacts[1]. This system ensured that a substantial portion of what the Penn Museum excavated in Nippur would return to Philadelphia while the rest would stay in the Ottoman Empire. However, by the terms of this agreement, Penn committed to ensure that all unique items would remain under the control of the Ottoman Empire. Not surprisingly, those objects were not held in Nippur but rather transported to the Ottoman imperial capital of Istanbul, which is now located in the Republic of Turkey. This arrangement planted seeds for later controversy, insofar as the collapse of the Ottoman Empire in the wake of World War I gave rise to new nation-states, like Iraq, whose leaders were inclined to see Mesopotamian antiquities as the rightful property of Iraq, and not of Turkey.
The Penn Museum began to excavate in Egypt in 1907, when the country was under British occupation. The British of course exerted an influence over Egyptian antiquities law. The Penn Museum agreed to partage with the British. In this case, half of the discovered artifacts returned with the Penn Museum to Philadelphia while half (jncluding unique objects) remained in Egypt under British control. As we begin to see, partage played an important role in many of the Penn Museum’s excavations.
In 1930, Dr. Frederick Wulsin led a Penn Museum excavation in Iran, most notably at the site of Tepe Gawra. While engaging in negotiations with the Persian Empire, the Museum even helped the government rewrite some of their antiquities laws. As evidenced by the document pictured below, the Persian government agreed to the same system of partage. Discussing archaeological prospects in Persia, Arthur Upham Pope of the Penn Museum wrote to the Persian Institute in 1930:
The foreign expeditions have a right to one-half of their finds, although a certain few objects of extreme and exceptional importance to Persian history will be retained by the Persian government in advance of a division of the finds.
We see again here that partage was key, and was becoming the normal modus operandi for the Penn Museum.
[1] Pezzati, Alessandro. "Penn Museum and Antiquity Laws." Personal interview. 25 Nov. 2014.
