Drawing Discrepancies

Archaeologists today still face certain challenges when trying to create precise drawings and revisit old ones. Sometimes drawings created in the past do not correspond well with the photographs taken of the objects and structures at the site. It is hard to reference these drawings since archeology is a destructive process. Dr. Darbyshire explained that a common problem was that many illustrators did not have training beforehand or a background in archeology. Time also played a crucial role in the accuracy of the drawings. It was not abnormal for the process to be in a terrible rush, prompted by zealous excavation directors wanting to reach “the most interesting layers”.  

Such discrepancies were found when archeologists revisited drawings from the Tepe Gawra excavation, including drawings that Alfred Bendiner produced. The archaeologists Brian Peasnall and Mitchell S. Rothman explained these points in an article that they published entitled, “One of Iraq’s Earliest Towns” [2002].

“First we reviewed the architect’s field drawings, the chits, and archival photographs to redraw the town plans and place the graves,” they wrote.  “In this effort, we found many mistakes in [the site directors'] Speiser’s and Tobler’s original publications. He interpreted many of them as sacrificial in nature, solely on the basis of their proximity to structures thought to have had a religious function. Two interpretive problems were thereby created. Stratigraphic attribution of burials based on this assumption often overruled sound principles of superposition, and new analyses showed that many buildings had functions other than those Tobler assigned them.”

Another challenge illustrators have had to overcome is stylization. While technologies such as stereo photography, computer renderings, and drones are tools that help create the finished product, it is still important for the illustrator to have a historical understanding of the findings. Perception is a subjective element and often leads to parallax-errors, involving discrepancies in proportion and spatial awareness of the objects. Archeologists must also balance how aesthetically pleasing a drawing is verses its accuracy. A very capable artist who lacks a historical knowledge may create a beautiful rendering, but completely miss the interpretive elements.