File #409: "Hart against Hill"

Title

Hart against Hill

Description

An 1836 lawsuit regarding a tract of land along the Delaware River and Darby Creek traces ownership back to a will executed in 1748. The main issue involved the use of that land to access the river to fish. Mary Hart accused Jacob Hill of trespassing on her property. Hill countered with the argument that regardless of who owned the land, he had the right to use the fishery.

Representing the plaintiff, Mr. Dick stated that "the main question is, did Sanderlin by the will of Christopher Taylor acquire a title to the soil on the bank of the river, or a mere easement... Now, it can be shown by the cases, that the ownership of land on tide water, extends to low water mark... The words 'fishing place' do not, either in common or technical language imply any right in the soil."

The case concluded in favor of the defendant

Creator

Reports of Cases Adjudged in the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, by Thomas I. Wharton, with references to cases in the subsequent reports, by John Sword, continued by I. Tyson Morris.

Source

Published by T. & J. W. Johnson & Co., Law Booksellers, Publishers and Importers, 1884.

Accessed at Google Books

Date

January 22, 1836