Title
Excerpt from Tinicum Fishing Company vs. Carter
Description
In July 1867, Paul B. Carter brought a lawsuit against the Tinicum Fishing Company for disturbing the productivity of the Carter fishery located below the Lazaretto. Carter's claim to the fishery was based on "long-continued possession," by which the uninterrupted use of a property for at least twenty-one conveys a title. He claimed that the walls, piers, and other infrastructure erected by the Tinicum Fishing Company encumbered his fishery. The case opened a discussion about what rights a riverfront property owner has over the adjacent water, where property boundaries lie in the case of tidal fluctuations of water level, and the seasonal variation of river conditions and therefore rights, among other issues. The lawsuit lasted several years and ultimately concluded in favor of Tinicum Fishing Company. In May 1870, Justice Sharswood declared that "it would be of very dangerous consequence...to all riparian proprietors upon navigable rivers, if by this sort of parol evidence of user, they could practically be deprived of their frontage, by being cut off from all the advantages of it for wharves, landings and other improvements."
Creator
Pennsylvania State Reports Containing Cases Decided by the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Source
Date
1867-1870
